1
This section covers the refrigeration cycle and its performance, the vapour compression cycle, eco-friendly refrigerants, absorption and adsorption refrigeration, and the processes used for gas liquefaction.
2
Principles and Coefficient of Performance • Refrigeration is the continuous removal of heat from a body at low temperature and its rejection to the surroundings at a higher temperature.
3
By the Clausius statement of the second law this cannot happen unaided, so a work or heat input is always required. • Coefficient of performance replaces efficiency, because the useful output exceeds the work input.
4
For a refrigerator, COP = QC/W = desired cooling/work input; for a heat pump, COP = QH/W; and since QH = QC + W it follows that COPheat pump = COPrefrigerator + 1, a relation frequently asked. • Carnot (maximum) values:
5
COPref,Carnot = TC/(TH − TC) and COPHP,Carnot = TH/(TH − TC), with temperatures in kelvin.
6
The immediate consequence is that the COP falls sharply as the temperature difference increases, which is why deep refrigeration is expensive and why the condenser should be as cool and the evaporator as warm as the duty permits. • Units: the tonne (ton) of refrigeration is the rate of heat removal required to freeze one short ton of water at 0 °C in 24 hours, equal to 3.517 kW (211 kJ/min, 12,000 BTU/h).
7
The Vapour Compression Cycle • This is the cycle of virtually every domestic refrigerator, air conditioner and cold store.
8
Its four components and four processes must be known exactly: • (1) Compressor — the low-pressure saturated vapour from the evaporator is compressed to high pressure and temperature; ideally isentropic, and this is where the work is supplied. • (2) Condenser — the hot high-pressure vapour is desuperheated and condensed at constant pressure, rejecting heat QH to the surroundings, leaving as saturated (or slightly subcooled) liquid. • (3) Expansion (throttle) valve or capillary tube — the liquid is expanded to the low pressure.
9
This is an isenthalpic throttling process, not an isentropic expansion: a valve is used rather than a turbine because the work recoverable from expanding a liquid is negligible and a turbine handling a two-phase mixture is impractical.
10
The temperature falls sharply and part of the liquid flashes to vapour. • (4) Evaporator — the cold two-phase mixture absorbs the refrigeration load QC at constant pressure and temperature, evaporating to saturated vapour, and returns to the compressor. • Representation: the cycle is drawn on the pressure-enthalpy (P-h) diagram, on which three of the four processes are straight lines — the throttling is vertical, and the condensation and evaporation are horizontal, which is why this diagram rather than T-s is used in refrigeration practice.
11
From it, COP = (h₁ − h₄)/(h₂ − h₁) — refrigerating effect divided by compressor work. • Practical modifications: subcooling the liquid leaving the condenser increases the refrigerating effect at no extra work and so raises the COP; superheating the vapour entering the compressor protects it from liquid slugging; multistage compression with flash intercooling is used for large temperature lifts; and cascade systems, in which two cycles with different refrigerants are thermally coupled, are used for very low temperatures.
12
Refrigerants and Environmental Considerations • Desirable properties of a refrigerant: a high latent heat of vaporisation (so that little needs to circulate), an evaporator pressure above atmospheric (so that air and moisture cannot leak in), a moderate condenser pressure, a low specific volume of vapour (a smaller compressor), chemical stability, non-toxicity, non-flammability and non-corrosiveness, miscibility with the lubricating oil, easy leak detection, low cost, and zero ozone depletion potential and low global warming potential. • The environmental history, which is examinable:
13
CFCs (R-11, R-12) were chemically ideal but release chlorine in the stratosphere and were the principal cause of ozone depletion; they were phased out under the Montreal Protocol (1987).
14
HCFCs (R-22) were the transitional substitutes, with a lower but non-zero ozone depletion potential, and are now also being phased out.
15
HFCs (R-134a, R-410A) have zero ozone depletion potential but high global warming potential, and are being phased down under the Kigali Amendment (2016). • Eco-friendly refrigerants now in use or under development:
16
HFOs (R-1234yf, R-1234ze) with very low GWP; and the natural refrigerants — ammonia (R-717), which has an excellent latent heat and zero ODP and GWP but is toxic and attacks copper, and is the standard in large industrial plants; carbon dioxide (R-744), non-toxic and non-flammable but requiring transcritical operation at very high pressure; hydrocarbons (propane R-290, isobutane R-600a), excellent thermodynamically and now standard in domestic refrigerators, but flammable; and water (R-718) and air for special applications. • Regulatory status changes with each amendment and national schedule, so the current position of any refrigerant must be verified before it is specified.
17
Absorption and Adsorption Refrigeration • Absorption refrigeration replaces the compressor — the only work-consuming component — with a thermally driven circuit, so that the system is driven by heat rather than by work.
18
Its components are the absorber, solution (liquid) pump, generator, condenser, expansion valve and evaporator, together with a heat exchanger between the strong and weak solution streams. • Operation: refrigerant vapour leaving the evaporator is absorbed into a liquid absorbent in the absorber, releasing heat; the solution pump raises the pressure of the liquid, which requires far less work than compressing a vapour; in the generator, heat is supplied to drive the refrigerant vapour out of solution; the vapour passes to the condenser and expansion valve as usual, while the weak solution returns to the absorber through a throttling valve. • The two systems: ammonia-water, in which ammonia is the refrigerant and water the absorbent, capable of temperatures below 0 °C and requiring a rectifier to remove water from the ammonia vapour; and lithium bromide-water, in which water is the refrigerant and lithium bromide solution the absorbent, limited to above 0 °C and therefore used for air conditioning and chilled water, with the advantages of a non-toxic refrigerant and no rectifier but the problems of crystallisation of the salt and the need for a deep vacuum. • Advantages: it uses low-grade heat — waste heat, steam, solar or a gas flame — so it is attractive where electricity is expensive or unavailable, has almost no moving parts and is therefore quiet and reliable, and uses environmentally benign fluids.
19
Disadvantages: a much lower COP (typically 0.5-0.8 for single-effect, against 3-5 for vapour compression), larger and more expensive equipment, and the need for a cooling water supply.
20
The comparison of COP is a standard examination question, and the point to make is that the two COPs are not directly comparable, because one is per unit of work and the other per unit of low-grade heat. • Adsorption refrigeration uses a solid adsorbent — silica gel, zeolite or activated carbon — instead of a liquid absorbent, with pairs such as silica gel-water, zeolite-water and activated carbon-methanol.
21
The bed alternately adsorbs refrigerant vapour (releasing heat) and is regenerated by heating (desorbing the vapour), so the operation is inherently intermittent and two beds are used alternately for continuous output.
22
It can use very low-grade heat (60-90 °C, and hence solar energy), has no moving parts and no corrosion or crystallisation problems, but has a low COP and a low specific cooling power, so the equipment is bulky. • Other refrigeration methods worth naming: steam-jet (ejector) refrigeration, air (Bell-Coleman) refrigeration, used in aircraft, thermoelectric (Peltier) cooling for small loads, vortex tube and magnetic refrigeration.
23
Liquefaction Processes • To liquefy a gas it must be brought below its critical temperature, since above that no pressure will condense it; the industrial problem is therefore one of cooling, and the three mechanisms available are heat exchange against a colder stream, Joule-Thomson throttling, and expansion in a turbine with the production of external work. • The Linde-Hampson process relies on Joule-Thomson throttling alone.
24
The gas is compressed, cooled against the returning cold stream in a counter-current heat exchanger, and throttled through a valve, where it cools further because μJT is positive; part liquefies and is withdrawn, and the remaining cold vapour returns through the heat exchanger to pre-cool the incoming gas — the regenerative cooling that progressively lowers the temperature until liquefaction begins.
25
It is simple and has no moving parts in the cold section, but has a low liquid yield and a high work requirement, and — the examinable point — it cannot be used for hydrogen, helium or neon at ambient temperature, because their inversion temperatures are below ambient, so throttling would warm them; they must first be pre-cooled with liquid nitrogen. • The Claude process improves on this by diverting part of the stream through an expansion engine or turbine, where it performs external work and therefore cools far more than by throttling alone, the remainder being throttled as before.
26
It gives a much higher yield and lower energy consumption at the cost of a machine operating at low temperature; the Heylandt process is a variant in which the expander works from ambient temperature, used for air. • Cascade liquefaction uses a series of refrigeration cycles with progressively lower-boiling refrigerants — for example propane, ethylene and methane — each condensing the next, and is the classical basis of LNG production; modern LNG plants use mixed refrigerant and propane-precooled mixed refrigerant (C3MR) processes. • Applications: air separation into oxygen, nitrogen and argon by cryogenic distillation of liquid air (the Linde double column);
27
LNG for transport and storage of natural gas, reducing its volume by a factor of about 600; liquid hydrogen and helium; storage and transport of industrial gases; and cryogenic preservation and superconductivity.
28
Cryogenic safety requires attention to cold burns, embrittlement of materials, oxygen enrichment and the asphyxiation hazard of an evaporating inert gas in a confined space.